9 Tips for Finding and Hiring Your Best SEO Consultant

With the best search engine optimization (SEO) consultant, businesses can expect an increase in search engine ranking, which helps customers find their business and consider using their services. However, not all consultants are experts in your industry or market.

This guide helps you find and hire the best SEO consulting services for your campaigns.

1. Define digital marketing goals
2. Ask for recommendations
3. Research online
4. Evaluate their website
5. Review their portfolio
6. Check references
7. Assess their expertise
8. Consider communication and transparency
9. Discuss pricing and contracts

Find the right SEO consultant for your needs. Let’s go!

Want to learn more about the Digital Authority Partners approach to SEO? Watch this video!

1. Define Your Goals

The first step in finding and hiring a consultant is for businesses to examine their marketing goals. What do they want to achieve with SEO? Do they want to improve organic search rankings, increase website traffic, or optimize conversions? With clear objectives, they can find a consultant that aligns with their goals.

Businesses can define their goals with these techniques.

• Evaluating their current situation and identifying areas that need improvement to determine what aspects of SEO they want to focus on.
• Identifying the target audience or customer base by understanding their demographics, interests, and online behaviors.
• Prioritizing objectives they want to achieve through SEO.
• Setting goals by making these specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART). For example, "increasing organic search traffic by 30% within six months."
• Assessing the competitors' online presence and strategies.
• Establishing a realistic timeline for achieving SEO goals. SEO is an ongoing process, and results may take time to materialize.
• Determining resources, including budget and personnel, to allocate for SEO efforts.

2. Ask for Recommendations

Seek recommendations from colleagues, business associates, or industry professionals with experience working with consultants. Personal referrals are valuable in finding reliable consultants who have provided excellent services. Follow these best practices.

• Identify relevant contacts. These individuals in the professional network may have knowledge or experience in SEO or digital marketing.
• Craft a personalized message to contacts. Express appreciation for their expertise and insights.
• Clearly state that you are seeking recommendations for a consultant.
• Emphasize trust and confidentiality. State that you value their opinions and trust their judgment.
• Ask for consultant recommendations based on their experiences or if they know someone who might provide valuable insights.
• Request additional details such as the results achieved, the consultant's communication style, professionalism, and other relevant information.
• Express gratitude for their time and willingness to provide recommendations.

3. Research Online

Use search engines and online directories to find consultants. Look for consultants with a strong online presence, positive reviews, and case studies showing their expertise and success. The following strategies can help when conducting online research:

• Use search engines such as Google, Bing, or Yahoo to find SEO consultants. Include keywords such as "best SEO consultant," "top SEO experts," or "SEO consultant [your location/industry]."
• Explore online directories and listings specific to consultants, such as Clutch, UpCity, or Moz's Recommended List of SEO Consultants.
• Visit the websites of consultants to evaluate their online presence. Pay attention to the quality of their website design, user experience, informative content, and blog posts.
• Look for testimonials or case studies on the consultant's website or other platforms.
• Search for reviews and ratings of consultants on platforms such as Google My Business, Yelp, or Trustpilot.
• Investigate the consultant's social media profiles, such as LinkedIn, Twitter, or Facebook.
• Participate in online forums or communities focused on SEO, such as Reddit, Quora, or other specialized forums.
• Look for consultants who publish thought leadership content, such as blog posts, articles, videos, or podcasts.
• Check interviews or podcasts featuring experts.
• Join online communities or groups related to SEO, digital marketing, or your industry on platforms such as LinkedIn, Facebook, or Slack.

4. Evaluate Their Website

Assess a potential consultant's website. A well-optimized, user-friendly website with high search rankings indicates knowledge and the ability to execute effective SEO strategies. Look for relevant keywords, informative content, and straightforward navigation. Follow these techniques to effectively evaluate a consultant’s site.

• Check design and user experiences, such as having a clean and visually appealing layout, easy navigation, clear calls-to-action, and fast loading times.
• Determine search engine visibility by using relevant keywords related to their services and location to see if their website prominently appears in search results.
• Evaluate the quality and relevance of the content on their website, such as blog posts, guides, case studies, or whitepapers that showcase their expertise and knowledge in SEO.
• Review the consultant's services and specializations to ensure they align with the business’s needs.
• Look for a portfolio or case studies highlighting the consultant's past projects and successes. (More on this later.)
• Read testimonials or reviews from previous clients posted on their websites or third-party platforms.
• Evaluate the consultant's involvement in the industry by checking certifications, awards, or memberships in reputable organizations or industry associations.
• Assess the consultant's accessibility and communication channels, including phone numbers, email addresses, or contact forms.
• Ensure the consultant adheres to ethical practices. Do not hire anyone who recommends the use of black hat SEO techniques or who makes unrealistic promises of overnight success.

5. Review Their Portfolio

Ask the consultant for examples of past projects and success stories. From their portfolio, check for evidence of their ability to improve search rankings, increase organic traffic, and drive business results. Pay attention to industries similar to yours to determine their relevant experience.

Reviewing a consultant’s portfolio is a critical step in assessing their capabilities and determining if they are the right fit. Here are some techniques to effectively review an SEO consultant's portfolio:

• Assess relevant information such as industry, business size, or goals. A portfolio demonstrating relevant experience shows a consultant to be someone who can better understand your business needs.
• Pay attention to the results and performance achieved in every project. Consider critical metrics such as organic traffic growth, search engine ranking improvements, conversion rate optimization, or revenue increases.
• Look for diverse projects in the consultant's portfolio, such as a range of industries, business types, and project sizes, because this shows adaptability and the ability to cater to different client needs.
• Evaluate the longevity and ongoing success of the projects presented in the portfolio.
• Identify the consultant's approach and strategies from case studies or project descriptions that provide insights into their methodology and specific techniques.
• Consider innovativeness and creativity in providing solutions to challenges.
• Assess the depth and breadth of the consultant's work across various aspects of SEO, such as technical optimization, on-page, and off-page strategies, local SEO, or content marketing.

6. Check References

Request references from the consultant and contact their previous clients. Ask about their experience working with the consultant, the results they have achieved, and their overall satisfaction. Doing so provides valuable insights into the consultant's professionalism and effectiveness.

Here are steps to effectively check consultants’ references:

• Request a list of clients who have worked with them on projects similar to yours.
• Contact the provided references and schedule a call or email exchange to discuss their experience working with the consultant. Ask these questions:

- How long did you work with the consultant, and what was your project?

- Did the consultant understand your goals and needs effectively?

- Did they regularly and promptly communicate with the client about progress and problems?

- What specific SEO strategies or techniques did they employ?

- Did the consultant deliver the expected results? If so, what were the outcomes?

- How did they handle challenges or setbacks during the project?

- Were they transparent about their methods?  Did they provide detailed reports or updates?

- How would you rate their professionalism, expertise, and overall satisfaction with their services?

- Would you recommend working with them, and why?

• Pay attention to the consistency and patterns in the feedback you receive from different references. Look for common experiences that validate the consultant's skills, professionalism, and effectiveness.
• Request specific examples or case studies from the references to illustrate the consultant's influence on their efforts.
• Cross-reference the information gathered from references with other sources such as the consultant's portfolio, case studies, or online presence.

7. Assess Their Expertise

A reliable consultant must deeply understand many SEO techniques and strategies. During interviews or discussions, ask about their approach to keyword research, on-page and off-page optimization, link building, content creation, and technical SEO.

Assess the expertise of a consultant using these techniques

• Review their website for indications of their expertise, such as informative blog posts, case studies, or whitepapers.
• Consider factors such as their years in business, the range of clients they have worked with, and the diversity of industries they served.
• Certifications and credentials from reputable organizations such as Google Analytics, SEMrush, or Moz indicate a solid understanding of SEO principles and best practices.
• Assess the consultant's thought leadership presence through blog posts, articles, videos, podcasts, or speaking engagements.
• Evaluate the consultant's involvement in the SEO community, such as participation in industry events, conferences, or webinars.
• Determine the consultant's technical knowledge by asking questions about website structure, XML sitemaps, URL canonicalization, schema markup, or website speed optimization.
• Request insights into their strategies and methodologies related to keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, content strategy, and analytics.
• Inquire about the consultant's methods of staying current, such as attending conferences, participating in training programs, or engaging in continuous learning.

8. Consider Communication and Transparency

Effective communication is crucial in a consulting relationship. Businesses must ensure that the consultant is responsive, listens to their concerns, and provides regular updates on progress and results. They must practice transparency about their methods to ensure ethical SEO practices. Here are ways to evaluate a consultant’s communication and transparency:

• Observe how the consultant communicates during your initial interactions, especially responsiveness, clarity, and professionalism.
• Determine their preferred communication channels and assess if they align with your preferences.
• Evaluate the consultant's response time. Timely communication is critical for addressing questions, concerns, or urgent matters.
• Assess the consultant's ability to clearly and understandably explain complex concepts and strategies.
• Inquire about the consultant's reporting and update process, especially types and frequency of updates, detailed reports, and insights into the key performance indicators (KPIs) they monitor.
• Evaluate if the consultant actively seeks to align their communication with your business goals. Do they prioritize open and transparent communication?
• Consider the consultant's collaboration style, such as open dialogue, feedback, and input.
• Assess the consultant's approach to tracking and reporting metrics. Look for transparent reporting, since this allows you to understand the effect of their efforts and the ROI of SEO initiatives.
• Evaluate how the consultant handles challenges or issues that arise during the project.

9. Discuss Pricing and Contracts

Understand the consultant's pricing structure or how they charge for their services. Some charge an hourly rate, a monthly retainer, or project-based fees. See to it that all parties understand the full extent of their obligations and any associated costs.

Carefully review the contract before signing, paying attention to terms and conditions, termination clauses, and confidentiality agreements. Remember these techniques.

• Familiarize yourself with standard pricing models in the SEO industry.
• Ask the SEO consultant for their pricing information upfront.
• Clarify the scope of work that the consultant's pricing covers.
• Inquire about the consultant's flexibility to customize services based on your needs.
• Ask the consultant about the value they bring to the table and how they measure ROI for their SEO services.
• Seek clarification on any potential hidden or additional fees. Understand the circumstances under which additional charges may apply.
• Discuss the consultant's preferred payment schedule and accepted payment methods.

Summing Up

Remember, finding the best SEO consultant is a process that requires careful evaluation and consideration. By following these techniques and conducting thorough research, businesses can increase their chances of finding a reputable consultant to help improve their website's visibility and organic search performance.

Find out how reputable SEO consulting services can benefit your business. Contact Digital Authority Partners for the most updated information.